Rebuilding E36 M3 Calipers

The brakes on the M3 Sedan have been untouched up until now, other than my replacing of the rotors a little while ago, so it was time for a good once over and caliper rebuild.

Caliper before RebuildDuring my work on the rear suspension, I noticed the caliper dust boots had slightly pulled out.  I’m sure the slider bushings need replacing as well.

I have an upcoming track day at Road Atlanta, so I also wanted to swap out the EBC Blue pads that came with the car for a set of PFC 08s I had previously used on the M Coupe.Worn EBC Pad  I wasn’t very impressed with the EBC Blue, which stopped the car well once up to temps but had poor initial bite and were a bit noisy.  I plan to keep the PFC 08’s on for the track weekend, then swap in some PFZ Z-rated for daily use (same as the M Coupe.)

I also noticed that the EBC pads had grooved the rotors pretty badly, so that would need addressed as well.  The pads were also tapered, the rears more so and also worn down.

So the brakes came off the car.  Since I was removing the lines at their connection to the hard line, I needed to plug the fitting or otherwise risk draining the system of brake fluid.  And believe me, you don’t want to try bleeding the entire system if you can help it!  I found that the little rubber caps used to protect bleed nipples worked perfectly for also plugging the double flare of the hard line.  Good to keep a handful of these around.

Bleed Screw Caps Plugged Brake Line

With the calipers off and the mounting bracket removed, the next step was to dislodge the piston.  This is done by using a blast of compressed air.  You’ll need an air-gun with a rubber tip to seal up against the brake line (or the hole in the caliper if the lines are removed.)  Get a large bucket or tray to place the caliper into, as you’ll get a nice blast of brake fluid when doing this (don’t forget your eye-pro).  You’ll also want to use a piece of wood to cushion the piston when it exits the cylinder, as it comes out with some force.  Be prepared for the loud “pop” as well!

Removing Caliper Piston

With the piston out, next comes the piston seal.  A dental pick works well to remove the seal from its recessed groove in the cylinder wall.  Take care that you don’t gouge the wall, which would create issues down the road.  With the calipers completely disassembled, I took them over to the parts cleaner for a good scrubbing.  I wasn’t looking to get them show-room clean, just remove the years of brake dust and road grime buildup.  After that I laid them out in the sun to dry off the kerosene.

Cleaning Calipers Calipers Drying

The pistons had quite a bit of surface rust on their exteriors (not the portion inside the cylinder thankfully), so I gave them a 24hr dunk in some Rust Eliminator.  With all the parts now dried, I gave all the pieces a good blast of brake cleaner, followed by some compressed air to make sure there weren’t any remaining particulates or kerosene residue.

Lube for seals and bootsBefore assembling the calipers, the seals and dust boots must be lubricated.  Now my first choice would have been some ATE assembly lube, but it’s not available in the US for whatever reason.  Don’t be fooled into use the ATE Plasti-Lube, which is intended for external use, as an “anti-squeal” lubricant.  It is a mineral based (petroleum) lubricant and can cause rubber seals to swell, which could create serious issues like a piston that won’t retract.  You need a silicone based lubricant made for use on rubber.  Many folks recommend Dow 111 or similar, such as Sil-Glyde, which can be found at NAPA.

I picked up a tube for this purpose, using it to grease the seal prior to installation.  You don’t need a heavy coat, don’t glob it on the cylinder wall.  It’s not going to be as heat resistant as brake fluid, it’s just used to lubricate the seals and boots for installation purposes.

Now for the most difficult part of the job; getting that dust boot seated.  For this step I went to the interwebs, specifically YouTube for any tips or tricks.  I had read and seen a few suggestions to seat the boot in its groove, insert the piston, then just push the boot into the caliper with a screwdriver or other blunt instrument.  Please do not do this!  You will more than likely damage the boot and even if you are lucky you will have a hell of a time getting the boot seated properly.  (Tip:  Buy an extra set of front and rear seals!)  Watch the video below for a better understanding (note the big tube of the previously mentioned ATE assembly lube):

httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nLFfsEmm_dg

As you can see the seal went in with ease.  It took me a little practice, but after the first one they all went together like butter.  The key is that you are actually inserting the lip of the boot into its groove prior to inserting the piston into the cylinder.  Therefore you have some wiggle room to feed the lip in, starting at the bottom.  I had a wooden popsicle stick on hand to help nudge it home where needed.

Boot prior to install Getting ready to install piston Piston partially installed

Take your time with this and it should work easily.  The Sil-Glyde certainly helps it all go together and works much better than just brake fluid.

Now on to the guide bushings.  The stock bushings are made of rubber, which is maintenance free and quiet.  Unfortunately it also allows for some unnecessary movement in the caliper and will deteriorate over time like any other rubber part.  This extra flex can lead to uneven pad wear, which was definitely visible on the EBC pads.  Tapered pads can reduce pedal feel and stopping power, things you like to eliminate in a sports car, especially in a track environment.  The alternative option is installing brass guide bushings, which eliminate the flex.  The downside is that they require regular maintenance to insure they are properly lubricated to prevent sticking.

These brass bushings can be found at several vendors, most notably BimmerWorld.  The install is pretty straight forward, with only a set of snap-ring (aka circlip) pliers as far as required special tools.  The old guide bushings came out easily enough by hand, just pull them through by grabbing a hold of the long inboard end.  A set of pliers can be used for extra motivation.

With the old bushings out, make sure you clean the now empty hole of any rust or debris.  I also applied a thin coat of high-temp copper anti-seize to insure they wouldn’t become corroded and stuck in the caliper.  The bushings are inserted from the rotor side of the caliper, so that the snap-ring groove is facing inboard.

On two of the front caliper bushings I had to do a small amount of clearancing, as there is a little variance in the casting which resulted in interference with the brass bushing sliding easily into the hole.  A die-grinder made quick work of this, though a hand file would work just as well.

Bushing clearance issue Clearancing caliper for bushing install

Installed bushing Snap-ring on Bushing

With the bushings installed in the caliper, next you must install the snap-rings from the backside.  Now onto the caliper brackets and the guide posts.  The BimmerWorld kit includes new posts, which look nearly identical to the stock posts, though I didn’t take a micrometer to them.  I clamped the center of the bracket in a bench vise to remove the OE guides, which requires a 7mm Allen socket.  The new ones go in and are torqued to 22 lb-ft.

Torquing sliders Caliper Brackets with greased sliders

You can see in the photo above that the guide posts received a light coat of copper anti-seize, as recommended by BimmerWorld.  There is certainly plenty of debate on what type of lubricant to use, and I contemplated using some moly dry-film lubricant or ceramic brake lubricant.  Since I see galvanic corrosion between the dissimilar metals being the main issue, the anti-seize is probably the best choice.  A light coat was also applied to bore of the brass bushings.  The fit tolerance is fairly tight, so the majority of the grease is going to be pushed out of initial assembly anyways.

NOTE:  As mentioned, these brass bushings require regular checks.  This isn’t much of a concern on a regularly track-driven car, because you are likely changing pads on a regular basis or at least checking the car prior to a track weekend.  Since there is no rubber dust boot, the necessary grease will attract dust and other grime.  Lack of lubricant or particulates lodged in the bushings can cause a caliper to stick, failing to properly retract and creating a dragging rotor.  For these reasons, it is recommended that these bushings be used for track or race cars rather than a regularly driven street vehicle, though many folks do use them on their street cars.  I intend to evaluate them during an upcoming track weekend.  I plan to swap pads following this event and will check them at that time and swap back to new OE rubber bushings if need be.  This is my daily-driver after all.

With work done on the calipers, now it’s time to put on the pads.  As previously mentioned, I had a set of lightly used PFC 08 pads and BimmerWorld titanium backing plates which I will be using for this upcoming even.  I’m fortunate that the M Coupe and M3 share their brake setups, allowing me to swap parts.  I have run these pads and plates at NOLA and COTA, where I was very impressed with the performance.  The 08 compounds did exhibit a small amount of pad fade at COTA towards the end of the session, but that’s not totally unexpected given the huge speed changes at the ends of two very long straights.  I was very pleased with the titanium backing plates, which shield the dust boots and caliper from the majority of the brake generated heat.  They came off the car scorched blue and purple, but the dust boots looked good as new.  The only downside is that they require the removal of the metal clip that slides into the piston, which leads to a little rattle noise when driving slowly and off the brakes.

Titanium backing plates PFC 08 Pads

Now for the rotors; a set of lightly used Centric blanks.  I had recently installed these on the M3, so rotor thickness was still very good, but the EBC pads had bedded and grooved them to a the point where I decided to have them turned smooth.  A local shop made quick work of them and left them looking almost like new.  Prior to installing the rotors, I applied a thin coat of the familiar copper anti-seize.  This helps to prevent rust and galvanic corrosion, which can lead to a rotor becoming stuck to hub.

Turned Rotors Copper Anti-seize on Hubs

On goes the rotor and caliper.  You may notice that I have a wheel bolt and two big nuts… okay, I have used two large nuts…. dangit, alright there are two large fastening devices and a wheel bolt used to secure the rotor to the hub.  The nuts were used simply as spacers since the bolt by itself would bottom out on the dust shield.  This was necessary due to the OE rotor bolt becoming seized into the hub, which required drilling out.  Of course this is only a temporary measure used to aid in installation of the caliper.

Caliper Installed

With the lines reconnected, the air must be bled off.  I topped off the reservoir using the same Brembo LCF 600 that I have been using, and hooked up my battered Motive pressure bleeder.  I worked my way around the car as normal, bleeding off all the air from the empty lines and calipers.  After that I gave the pedal a few pumps to push the pistons out until the pads made contact with the rotors, then rebled the system a second time.

Bleeding Brakes

And that’s it.  Not too difficult, and the brakes should be good to go another 130k miles or 16 years.

Speed Bleeders Strike Again!

In my most recent post I covered the many headaches involving the brakes on my M Coupe, which was solved by replacing the Speed Bleeders with normal OEM style bleed screws.  This upcoming weekend I plan to take my MR2 Spyder to the track, and as part of the track preparations, I always check the brakes (among a slew of other items.)  Well, I remembered that I had also installed Speed Bleeders on my MR2, better pull them and take a look…

Spyder Speed Bleeders Yep, four more mangled bleeders.  That makes 10 for 10 that were damaged.  I know some of you are going to say I was just over-tightening them.  If you were to read my other post, you’d see that I tested two brand new ones by only tightening them until the fluid flow stopped, yet they were still damaged, albeit not to this extent.  I’m also tightening them to the same torque I’ve always used on any car I’ve done brakes on.  I’m no metallurgist, but I’d guess the grade steel these are made of is too weak, or perhaps they machined too much away to accommodate the check valve assembly.  It’s really a moot point, as I’ll never be using them again.  Back to good old, plain OEM-style bleeders.

The good news is that the BMW and Toyota use the same size bleed screws, and I had ordered 4 extras when I was replacing the M Coupe’s.

The Great Brake Debacle of 2013… and some of 2014

You may recall the numerous issues I’ve been experiencing with the M Coupe’s brakes.  It seemed no matter what I did, I was left with a soft pedal.  Some of that was originally attributed to fade caused by overheating, which I experienced with the OEM pads and fluid.  Several fluid and pad changes had made small improvements, but the pedal was still not acceptable to me.  I continued to track it, but was continuously bleeding the brakes before, during, and after events.  But with an upcoming BMW CCA Club Racing School coming up, I knew I had to do something, especially for driving in such close proximity to other cars.

I had already attempted to bleed the master cylinder while still mounted in the car, by jacking up the rear of the car to level out the cylinder.  While this should have worked in theory, the pedal remained limp.  So I did it the correct way this time, completely removing the cylinder from the car and bench bleeding it.  I used a master bleed kit from NAPA, which comes with several different size ports to bleed a wide variety of domestic and foreign cars.  I actually purchased two of these kits, as the M Coupe’s master cylinder has three ports that must be bled, a product of its DSC and ABS setup.

Bench Bleed Master Bottom Bench Bleed Master

So bench bleeding complete, back in the master cylinder goes.  NOTE: Always lube the o-ring that creates the seal between the vacuum booster and master cylinder.  I failed to do this on my Spyder once, and I ended up wasting money on a brand new booster when is was just a dried up $2 o-ring.  With the lines disconnected, then reconnected, air is destined to be introduced into the lines, and worse, into the labyrinth that is the ABS manifold.  The only way to truly bleed these modern systems is to electrically actuate the various pumps, valves, and corresponding solenoids.  The dealer would normally do this with a very expensive proprietary computer system.  Fortunately for us mere mortals, some very smart tinkers have cracked the code and versions of this software are available online and via eBay.  I have just such a device, which runs on a $100 used Dell laptop I also found on eBay.  The program, called DIS (sometimes referred to as GT1), allows me to bleed (ventilate in BMW parlance) the system.  The system must also be pressurized in order to properly do this, which a Motive pressure bleeder does nicely.

GT1 Bleeding Program Pressure Bleeding Brakes

Rather than waste even more money on expensive brakes fluids (thus far I’ve ran through gallons of ATE, Motul, and Brembo LCF), I just picked up several liters of AutoZone brand fluid.  I would use the cheap stuff to just flush out and bleed the system, until I had a solid pedal.  I ran through the routine as I normally would, nothing out of the ordinary.  I was getting a decently solid pedal, that is until I cranked the engine and had vacuum assist.  At that point the pedal would begin to get softer, softer with every additional full-throw pedal engagement.  I was stumped.  I quickly inspected everything, but nothing jumped out at me.  I did, however, notice my PFC Z pads were getting rather thin.  They weren’t yet to the point where replacement was absolutely necessary, but I was concerned, given I had the Race School and a track weekend at COTA coming up.  So I decided to pull the pads, perhaps this would solve my pedal issue (though physics says otherwise.)

The results weren’t comforting.  The pads were all cracked right down the center, all of them.  This could have been any number of things, I’m no brake pad expert.  I suspect that they simply were over-used, given that the Z pads are intended for performance street driving, and I was using them very hard at some fairly quick tracks.

Cracked Pads Up Close Cracked Pads

Fortunately half my house has become a bit of a BMW/Toyota/Nissan parts store, and I had a set of PFC 08 pads.  See, the E36 M3 using exactly the same brakes as the M Coupe, or rather the M Coupe uses E36 M3 brakes.  I had purchased the 08 compound pads for my M3, as they are PFC’s new endurance race compound, making them great for DEs.  I also had a set of Bimmerworld’s titanium backing plates.  These thin metal pieces are shaped just like the pads and go between the piston and the pad.  Titanium doesn’t transmit heat nearly as much as steel, definitely not as much as aluminum, so it makes for a great shield against pad/rotor heat destroying dust boots, piston seals, and boiling the brake fluid.  In order to install them, the spring clip which fits into the piston must be removed.  This clip isn’t necessary for the brakes to function, it just reduces the likelihood of the brakes rattling or squealing.  The clip is simply riveted into the back of the pad, and can be pried out easily.

New and Old Pads New vs Old Pads

Clip Installed Clip Removed

 

The new pads were installed and everything torqued back down, just like I’ve done probably a hundred times.  I did another bleed, checked the pedal, cranked the engine, checked the pedal again…. still soft.  I was about to give up, but logic was saying that it couldn’t be air in the system, that fluid had to be leaking somewhere.  So I went around to every caliper, cleaning everything with brake cleaner, and allowing it to dry.  I then cranked the engine and pumped the brakes again.  I went around with a flashlight and closely inspected every line, connector, fitting, and of course the calipers for leaks.  That’s when I noticed that a couple of the bleed valves were wet with brake fluid.  Not only that, but there was a little wet spot directly across from the nipple on the inside of the fender liners on the back right and front right.  I cleaned everything meticulously again, then tried the brakes with the engine running another time.  I got out and inspected again, sure enough, wet with fluid.  Not a lot of fluid mind you, but then again it doesn’t take much when you consider just how little the pads are moving.

I tightened the two culprit bleed valves (aka bleed screws, aka bleed nipples) just a smidgen more, just in case they weren’t completely seated.  Then I tried the whole effort again, only to discover it was still a soft pedal and I still had fluid weeping from the valves.  About then is when I remembered that I had installed Speed Bleeder valves on this car (as I had on most of my cars.)  The Speed Bleeder is a simple idea, incorporating a check valve into the bleeder, so that air can not enter the system.  This should allow for easy one-man bleeding, as you can open the valves and just pump.  I decided to remove the two valves and replace them with a new set of Speed Bleeders I had on hand.  Sure enough, both valves were deformed, crushed at their tips.  Strange, as I only ever use a small (well what other kind of 8mm wrench is there) wrench to tighten the valves closed.  I was just about to begin the entire bleeding process over when my pessimism took over.  What if the other two remaining valves were similarly damaged?  Better to find out now than at the track, so I backed the other valves out; sure enough, crushed just like the others.

Speed Bleeder Packaging Deformed Speed Bleeders

I decided to do a little experiment, to see if it was me over-tightening them, or just a weak design (well really both.)  I installed four brand new Speed Bleeders, lightly tightening each of them.  Then I pressurized the system.  I pumped the brakes a bit, checked each valve for leaking, and leaking I found.  So I tightened them a bit more and repeat.  I did this a few times until I couldn’t see any more leakage.  At that point I backed all the bleed screws back out and inspected them.  As I suspected, each was slightly deformed.  Not nearly as badly crushed as the originals, but still deformed.  Not too confidence inspiring given that these were fresh out of the package.  That was it for Speed Bleeders, time to go back to the tried and true plain old bleeder valves.

I purchased a new set (plus spares) of bleed valves.  I didn’t go with the BMW OEM valves, as they use a rather small 7mm hex, which is easily rounded.  I used some Dorman valves in the same taper, pitch, and size as stock, but with an 8mm hex.  I added some brake thread sealant, which must be baked on at 200F for about ten minutes.  New Bleed ValvesWith everything back together, I went back to bleeding.  Full of hope, I cranked the engine and pushed the brake pedal; Success!!  The pedal feel that I so longed for was finally restored.  The pedal remained solid, allowing for much easier heel-toe shifting.  The following weekend I was able to put the brakes through their paces at TWS during the Club Racing School, and they performed flawlessly.  Sure the new 08 pads squealed a bit, but the feel was so much better, it truly transformed the drive.  I could brake deeper, more consistently, with much more confidence.  I didn’t experience any fade the whole weekend, the first time I wasn’t on my back between sessions bleeding the brakes.  This just goes to show that sometimes it’s the simplest of things than can create the biggest and most complicated of issues.  I should have started with the simple to fix items when I began troubleshooting months ago, I would have saved myself a lot of time, headache, and especially money blown in brake fluid.  Let this be a lesson to others, you’re often better off sticking with OEM, especially when dealing with bleed valves!

Computerized Brake Bleeding

I was tired of a somewhat spongy brake pedal at the track in the M Coupe, so I decided to go a couple steps further in the bleeding process.  The complexities of the modern car’s ABS system mean there are numerous spots where air can become trapped in the system.  There are a few different techniques to dislodge this air, like forcing the ABS to engage by braking over a slippery surface like wet grass.  Rather than do this, I looked to the factory/dealer prescribed method, which uses a special BMW authored software called DIS.  I didn’t have a laptop with the software running (it’s notoriously finicky to setup and run) so I put out an SOS to the Bimmerforums Texas sub-forum.  Fortunately a follow enthusiast in Austin offered to let me borrow his setup.  It worked like a charm, cycling the primer pump and actuating the valves, with very basic on-screen instructions.  The dealer would have a wheeled bleeder cart to pressurize the system, whereas I have a simple Motive pressure bleeder.  I first flushed the system with some cheap parts store fluid to try to get any bub

DIS Bleed Program Motive Power Bleeder

Pressure Bleeder IMG_6994

I’ve since purchased my own copy of the software and installed it on an old beat up Windows XP laptop, more to come on that.  I’ve also since switched to Brembo LCF 600 brake fluid, which seems to have a slightly better pedal feel than the Motul.  Due to a full garage and a steep driveway, I had to do that work in the street.  I knew those traffic cones would come in handy. UPDATE:  Please read this thread to see the source of all the brake pedal woes. Redneck Garage

New Brake Pads, Rotors, and Fluid for the MR2 Spyder

Since the MR2 Spyder is going to be doing a little track duty in the near future, it was damn near mandatory that it receive some love in the braking department.  The MR2 Spyder (aka MR-S, aka MkIII) is renown for its stock brakes capabilities, hugely attributable to its light weight and rear weight bias.  That, however, doesn’t get past the most common issue that street cars face on the track; brakes overheating, which leads to fade.  I experienced it in my M Coupe, which arguably is much better suited for track duty with stock cooling ducts and other factory performance features.  So, I hit the interwebs in search for a good set of pads for DE usage.  The Carbotech XP8s came back with several recommendations, sounding rather comparable to PFC’s 08’s (had Performance Friction produced pads for the MR2, I would have gone that route.)  I also picked up some Centric rotors, as my EBC UBR rotors looked terrible, all the slots were full of pad deposit.  I decided to stick with blanks this time.

For fluid I originally filled the car with ATE Super Blue, because I had lots of it and it’s inexpensive.  But after several track days of having fade with the ATE, I decided to ditch it and go with some Motul 600 that I also had laying around.  Since the higher heat also affects things like anti-squeal grease, I also went with some ultra-high temp Permatex ceramic grease, which is thick and purple.  The hub faces also got a little coat of anti-seize to prevent any stuck rotor situation. I have to mention that the Toyota brakes are much more of a pain to replace pads on than the BMW, surprised right?  On a side note, I would have had this job done much sooner, had I not mistakenly ordered the wrong rear (5 lug) rotors!

Motul 600 Brake Fluid New Centric Rotor on the Spyder

Parts and pieces layed out for Brake Job Some of the tools for a brake job

…and yes a large C-clamp makes an excellent brake piston tool